Between 2010 and 2014, I worked on a donor-funded youth enterprise fund in one region of MENA. Millions were set aside for enterprises led by young people aged 18 to 35. When the portfolio was finally added up by sector, it read like a list of the region’s oldest trades: arts and crafts, leather, carpentry, metal smithing.
Nobody designed it that way. The eligibility rule did.
A Rule That Asked Almost Nothing
The eligibility criteria were generic. Anyone under 35 living in the region could apply. There was no innovation criterion, no enterprise criterion, and no test of whether a business would grow, hire or change anything in the local market. On paper, the door was wide open.
In practice, one filter decided everything: credit scoring. The applicant’s credit score and repayment capacity ruled the decision. Nothing else was screened out, because nothing else was screened.
The Contradiction Inside the Design
A youth enterprise fund exists because young people are the ones a lender will usually not finance: no credit history, no collateral, no proven cash flow. A credit score and a repayment-capacity test select for the opposite profile, the applicant who already runs a business with steady income.
So the money went where the score pointed. Established, often family-run trade businesses passed. First-time founders with a new idea mostly did not. The region’s economy was artisan-heavy and agricultural, young people had little interest in either, and the fund still had to disburse. It financed the businesses that cleared the score.
That is a credit line with an age limit, not an enterprise fund. Every loan could be justified on its own. The portfolio as a whole answered a question nobody had asked.
What Has Changed
This has changed for the better. Youth and enterprise funds today put innovation at the center of their criteria: what problem the venture solves, what is new in the product or the model, and whether it can grow. That shift matters, because it changes who reaches the committee in the first place.
It does not make the lesson obsolete. A fund that adds an innovation criterion and keeps a conventional credit score as the final gate will still end up with a conventional portfolio. The criterion that decides is the one that counts, not the one written first.
Four Questions Before the Call Goes Out
These belong in the diagnostic, before design starts, as I argued in Diagnose First, Design Second.
- What portfolio do we want in year three, by sector and by type of founder?
- Which criterion will actually decide, and does it select for that portfolio or against it?
- If young applicants have no credit history, what replaces the credit score: a business plan review, a pilot sale, a mentor’s assessment, a guarantee?
- When disbursement targets meet thin demand, do we wait, redesign, or lend to whoever qualifies?
The eligibility rule is the first design decision a fund makes, and usually the most powerful one. Write it for the portfolio you want, because it will write the portfolio either way.
Work With Me on This
I help donors and fund managers design eligibility and selection criteria that select for what the program is meant to build.