Open almost any program report, fund presentation or company profile from the last five years and you will find three words close together. The project “contributes to SDGs 1, 5 and 8.” The partner bank has “a strong ESG profile.” The fund “delivers impact.”
Each word does real work somewhere. Used together, without the question behind each one, they cancel each other out.
Three Words, Three Questions
The Sustainable Development Goals answer a question about the world: what must change by 2030, and how far countries are from it. They are 17 goals and 169 targets that governments report against. The latest UN report is blunt. Only 35 percent of the targets are on track or making moderate progress, and 18 percent have gone backward.
ESG answers a question about a company: how environmental, social and governance issues affect its risk and its value. It is an investor’s question, asked from the outside in. A strong ESG rating says a company manages these risks well. It does not say the company changed anything for the people it serves.
Impact answers a question about change: what is different for people or the planet because of what you did, that would not have happened otherwise. The Impact Management Project, the sector’s consensus effort on this question, framed it as five dimensions: what changed, for whom, how much, what your contribution was, and the risk that the change does not happen as expected.
Goal, risk, change. Three questions, and three readers: governments, investors, and the people a program exists to serve.
How the Label Replaces the Question
The frameworks are not the problem. The problem starts when a label stands in for the question it was built to answer.
An SDG icon tells the reader which goal you care about. It does not tell them whether you moved it. Mapping activities to goals is an act of naming: every training program can claim SDG 8 and every women’s program can claim SDG 5. When nearly everything maps, the map stops carrying information.
ESG ratings, read as a measure of good, mislead even on their own terms. A study of six major rating agencies found that their scores diverge widely, and that about 56 percent of the disagreement comes from how the same category is measured, not from what is included. Two raters can look at the same company and reach different conclusions about the same issue.
Impact is most often used for reach: people trained, loans disbursed, enterprises “supported.” Reach is an output. Impact is what is different afterward, and how much of it would have happened anyway.
I have made the same argument about “gender” labels on finance products. A label on a product does not remove a single barrier a woman faces. SDG and ESG labels work the same way. They describe an intention. They do not show a change.
Look Beneath the Label
Event: a report carries SDG icons, an ESG score and an impact headline.
Pattern: labeled capital grows while outcomes stall. Impact investing assets reached USD 1.571 trillion in 2024, up more than USD 400 billion in two years, managed by more than 3,900 organizations. In the same period, the UN found most SDG targets off track. These two numbers measure different things, and that is exactly the point. When the political mood turned, the labels moved faster than the portfolios: sustainable funds saw outflows through 2025, and European sustainable funds posted their first annual net outflows, USD 61 billion, since Morningstar began tracking the region in 2018.
Structure: reporting rewards alignment because alignment is cheap to show and change is expensive to prove. Each funder, investor and regulator asks for its own format, and the organization at the end of the chain, often the smallest, fills all of them. Measurement budgets are thin, so the cheapest claim wins. The DCED Standard, built to measure change across a whole market, is used by around 120 projects in more than 50 countries. That is a small share of the field.
Regulation is moving, and it is moving on the ESG question. In Egypt, Financial Regulatory Authority Decrees 107 and 108 of 2021 require non-bank financial institutions and listed companies to disclose their ESG practices each year, with climate disclosures for companies whose issued capital or equity exceeds EGP 500 million. That is real progress for transparency. It is also, by design, a disclosure of practices. It answers how a company manages risk, not what changed for the enterprises and households it finances.
Mental model: “If we report it, we have done it.”
What Changes When You Ask the Right Question
For program designers and implementers, five practical moves:
- Name the question behind every claim. Goal, risk or change. If a sentence uses SDG language to claim a change, it needs evidence of change.
- Choose one target, not five goals. State the indicator you can move at your scale. Women’s financial inclusion is a good example. In Arab low- and middle-income economies, 31 percent of women and 47 percent of men have an account. That 17-point gap is more than three times the average gap across low- and middle-income economies. A program that names its share of that gap, in its own governorate or market, says more than a row of SDG icons.
- Report reach as reach. People trained and loans disbursed are outputs. Keep them, label them, and do not call them impact.
- Make contribution explicit. Ask what would have happened without the program, and how you will know. This is the dimension most reports skip.
- Use ESG for what it is. It is a useful risk lens when you choose a financial institution or a corporate partner. It is not evidence of results for the people you serve.
For funders and investors, the move is simpler and harder: ask for the five dimensions, and budget for measuring them. A reporting template that asks for SDG alignment will get SDG alignment. A template that asks who changed, by how much and with what contribution will get a different conversation.
Alignment is a direction. A rating is a risk reading. Impact is a change you can show. Mix them, and a report can look greener every year while nothing below the surface moves.
Work With Me on This
I design programs and results frameworks for donors, implementers and financial institutions that measure what changed, not only what was delivered.
Common Questions
ESG measures how environmental, social and governance issues affect a company’s risk and value. Impact measures what changed for people or the planet because of an organization’s work, including how much of that change would not have happened otherwise.
No. Alignment states which goal an activity relates to. Impact requires evidence that the activity moved an indicator under a specific target, for a defined group, by a measurable amount.
Start from a results chain, define indicators of change for the enterprises served, separate outputs from outcomes, and assess contribution against what would have happened anyway. The DCED Standard and the five dimensions of impact give a tested structure for this.
It can, when it improves a lender’s or buyer’s view of risk. But disclosure rules mostly cover larger and listed companies, and the data requests that flow down supply chains often fall on small firms without the systems to answer them.
Further Reading
For readers who want to go deeper, these are the pieces I recommend, from practical standards to the debate on ESG.
- UNDP, SDG Impact Standards for Enterprises. How to move from claiming alignment with the SDGs to managing and showing a contribution to them.
- Impact Frontiers, The ABC of Enterprise Impact. The successor to the Impact Management Project, with the shared norms behind the five dimensions of impact.
- GIIN, IRIS+ System. The most widely used catalog of impact metrics, organized by theme and by the five dimensions.
- DCED, The DCED Standard for Results Measurement. The practical standard for measuring change in private sector development and market systems programs.
- Berg, Kölbel and Rigobon, “Aggregate Confusion: The Divergence of ESG Ratings” (2022). Why two ESG ratings of the same company can point in different directions.
- Alex Edmans, “The End of ESG,” Financial Management (2023). A respected finance scholar argues that ESG should be treated as ordinary good business practice, not a separate category.
- Aswath Damodaran, “Sounding Good or Doing Good? A Skeptical Look at ESG” (2020). A sharp valuation-side critique of what ESG scores can and cannot tell an investor.
- Ronald Cohen, Impact: Reshaping Capitalism to Drive Real Change (2020). The case for measuring impact as seriously as profit, from one of the founders of impact investing.
Sources
- United Nations, The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2025, press release (July 2025): https://unstats.un.org/sdgs/files/report/2025/SDG_Report_2025_Press_Release_EN.pdf
- Global Impact Investing Network, Sizing the Impact Investing Market 2024 (October 23, 2024): https://giin-web-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/giin/assets/press-release/giin-sizingthemarket-pressrelease-2024.pdf
- Morningstar, sustainable fund flows Q4 2025, via Portfolio Adviser: https://portfolio-adviser.com/sustainable-fund-outflows-slow-in-q4/
- Berg, Kölbel and Rigobon, “Aggregate Confusion: The Divergence of ESG Ratings,” Review of Finance (2022): https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3438533
- Impact Management Project, five dimensions of impact, as summarized by the DCED (April 2019): https://www.enterprise-development.org/wp-content/uploads/RM-Brief-IMP-Standard.pdf
- DCED, Measuring Results: The DCED Standard: https://www.enterprise-development.org/measuring-results-the-dced-standard/
- Financial Regulatory Authority Decrees No. 107 and 108 of 2021 (Egypt), Climate Change Laws of the World: https://www.climate-laws.org/geographies/egypt/policies/financial-regulatory-authority-decrees-no-107-and-108
- World Bank, Global Findex 2025, Arab World note: https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/145df06f1b02813f508616d49c7d37d3-0050012026/original/Findex-Note-Arab-World.pdf