Every few months a financial institution announces a product for women. Smaller ticket size, a lower interest rate for the launch period, sometimes a pink brochure. The product is reported as a gender-sensitive finance initiative. Eighteen months later uptake is modest, the portfolio looks like the institution’s existing portfolio with a different label, and the conclusion drawn is that women do not want credit.
What are the real systemic barriers preventing finance from being gender-sensitive? How can we zoom out and analyze the larger picture before we design another product around the one barrier that is easiest to name?
Access Is the Symptom
Access is the barrier everyone can measure, so it is the barrier everyone designs for. But in the national assessments I have led on women’s and youth entrepreneurship, access rarely came first in women’s own account of what stood between them and growth. What came first was the socio-cultural setting that determined whether a woman could travel to a branch, hold an account in her own name, sign without a guarantor from the household, or be seen by a male loan officer. Then came the regulatory environment: registration requirements, collateral rules, identification documents. Then the market itself: sectors women were concentrated in, margins those sectors allowed, buyers who paid late. Access to finance sat on top of all of that, and a product that addressed access alone addressed the top of the iceberg.
Design Around All the Barriers
Gender-sensitive finance, done properly, starts from a gender analysis of the system and designs the intervention around the full set of barriers rather than the financial one. In practice that has meant, in projects I have designed and managed: appraisal methods that do not depend on collateral women cannot hold; women loan officers and delivery points women can reach; non-financial services, from registration support to market linkages, bundled with the loan rather than offered beside it; and, where the barrier was the household, working with the household rather than around it.
It has also meant being honest about which barriers a financial institution can move and which need a regulator, a municipality or a buyer. That is where a market systems lens earns its place. The institution is one actor in a system that is producing the exclusion, and the product is one lever among several.
The Design Test
Here is the test I apply before I let anyone put ‘gender’ on a product. Take the label off. Is there anything left in the design that a product for men would not have? If the only difference is the ticket size and the brochure, the product is not gender-sensitive; it is a general product with a target group.
Gender-sensitive finance is designed around the barriers women actually face, not around the one barrier institutions find easiest to measure.
Most consultants and program implementers in our sector overlook this, not because of a lack of commitment, but because a systemic analysis takes longer than a product launch and does not fit a results framework that counts loans disbursed to women. The institutions that have done the harder work have the portfolios to show for it. The rest keep concluding that women do not want credit.
I also run this analysis as hands-on training for financial institutions and program teams, working from their own products and client data.
Work With Me on This
I work with institutions and companies on women’s economic empowerment models. See the Service →