Zoom Out · November 2026 · 4 min read

Evaluating Financial Inclusion Programs: What Reports Keep Missing

Financial inclusion programs are counted well and evaluated rarely. Three things endline reports keep missing: usage, who delivers after the program, and the norm behind the number.

The endline report says the program opened more accounts than its target. Everyone applauds. Nobody asks how many of those accounts moved a single transaction after the first month.

Counting is not evaluating. Financial inclusion programs are counted well and evaluated rarely.

Why the Count Is So Comfortable

The SEEP Network’s 2013 paper on monitoring change in market systems made a plain point: conventional monitoring and evaluation assumes a level of control and predictability that market systems do not offer. It named three habits that follow. Programs over-focus on direct effects. They put donor accountability ahead of learning in the field. They define sustainability as the program lasting, not the system adapting.

An account count fits all three habits. It is direct, it satisfies the donor, and it says nothing about what happens after the program leaves.

Three Things Reports Skip

Usage, and who stays. An account that is opened and never used is access without inclusion. The regional numbers show the size of the gap. In low- and middle-income Arab economies, about 40 percent of adults had an account in 2024, but only 13 percent saved formally in one. For women the figures were 31 and 8 percent; for men, 47 and 17. The question for the report is who is still transacting at month six and month eighteen, and what they are doing with the account.

Who does the work now. If the provider still depends on program funding for training, outreach or technology, the system has not changed. It has a new logo on the same dependency. The DCED guidance on systemic change asks the right test: is the change sustainable, scalable and resilient without the program?

The norm behind the number. CGAP’s 2022 diagnostic guidance on gender norms, tested in several countries including Egypt, starts from the finding that social norms shape women’s financial behavior alongside regulation and supply-side barriers. A report that disaggregates by gender and stops there has counted the women without asking what shapes their use.

Zoom Out and the Picture Changes

Event: a program reports accounts opened and little else.
Pattern: evaluations measure what the log-frame fixed at the start.
Structure: indicators set for donor accountability, reviewed at the end.
Mental model: access is inclusion.

Institutions stay at the event because the log-frame is a contract. Changing an indicator midway feels like admitting the design was wrong, so the count continues.

Evidence Does Not Have to Be Perfect

CGAP’s 2014 review of impact evidence leaned on randomized and quasi-experimental studies rather than assumed benefits, and rightly so where the question is attribution. DCED’s guidance says that, where the question is system change, well-run interviews with market actors, triangulated with secondary data, are enough.

Use the strong design where the question is attribution and triangulation where it is system change. Do not force one tool on both.

DCED’s three universal indicators, scale, net income change and jobs, also make results comparable across programs. Use them, and then add the one indicator the program needs that they do not cover.

Count the accounts. Then ask who still uses them, and why.

Work With Me on This

I design and lead evaluations of financial inclusion programs that ask who still uses the service, who delivers it now, and why.

See the Service →

Sources

← All Perspectives

Organizations I Have Worked With
USAIDGlobal Affairs CanadaWorld BankCentral Bank of EgyptCommercial International BankIFCKfWEuropean UnionHabitat for Humanity InternationalAga Khan Agency for MicrofinanceDrosos FoundationUN WomenUN-HabitatLFS AdvisoryGoss GilroyEnvironment and Development GroupAECOMFINBI